#IAMondays: Interactive Movies

Wayne recently tweeted a link to an interactive movie, which was a fascinating experience. It shared some traits that relate to the concept I wrote about on the difference between linear and nonlinear stories, but there are some key differences here.

One of the key differences between this interactive movie and another type of nonlinear story is that this one is more easily repeatable. A user types their address into the site before the movie begins, and the movie then plays with Google Earth images of the user’s own hometown and address. I can share my movie with others so that they can see how the movie plays out in my hometown. There do seem to be minor differences… after watching the movie four times, it seems like some of the camera angles are randomized. The basic scenes are the same, however, as long as I type in the same address. This can be seen as an advantage over an interactive story with many more forking paths, since those types of stories seem to be hard to repeat without remembering the specific path you took through all of the steps.

Another advantage is that the same basic “story” can be seen by anyone with their own address added in. I can type in a new address, and essentially the same movie plays, with the only real difference being a different set of Google Earth images for the new location. The other elements (the running man, the birds, the trees, and the song) remain the same for each user. I mentioned in my previous blog post that nonlinear stories make it difficult for two users to share the same experience, including their ability to discuss what the experience was like. This interactive movie, however, gives everyone a very similar experience, with just a touch of personalization.

Of course, the disadvantage is that there isn’t a LOT of customization available here. Nonlinear stories have the advantage of being able to be experienced differently each and every time. This interactive movie, while it can be personalized for each user, is very close to the same every time it is played.

The balance here seems to be in how much decision the user is given in the course of a story. In a completely linear story, the user is essentially given no choice but to move forward and experience the story as it exists. In a nonlinear story, the user has a great deal of control, and their every decision can affect the outcome of the story. The amount of control given affects how customizable a story is. This interactive movie only gives the user a small number of decisions to make, and as a result the path of the story won’t ever change very much.

I think this idea of freedom versus control is at the core of making any type of nontraditional interactive story or movie. If you give the user too much control, it can be hard to maintain any sense of continuity in a story. If you give the user too little control, the story won’t really be interactive or customizable. The amount of control you give should be carefully and deliberately decided based on what type of story (linear or non) you want to create.

Categories: #IAMondays | Tags: , , , , , | 4 Comments

Post navigation

4 thoughts on “#IAMondays: Interactive Movies

  1. I think control is still quite tightly controlled in elit. As discussed in class, there are still quite codified structures to elit, despite it’s more “random” word appearances. The code is a hierarchy and its parameters determine when and where words should appear. This is not slapdash but as much an artistic choice as it would be in any other piece. It is not as if things are plucked from the ether for an appearance. Constructing meaning might be more of a free-form activity, but I do not think that the user/reader of a nonlinear story really has as much control as you think.

  2. I think the interactive movie, at least this example, doesn’t give the reader/viewer/user as much control as in other examples. I feel like the only control I have is over which play the movie takes place. I don’t know if I did it wrong, because Devon and I both did this at the same exact time but with different addresses, and I’m pretty sure we had the same exact movie. So then, I’m not sure that there is anything different between the different addresses or not. Then again, I might’ve did it wrong, which is just another example of the risks that we are involved in as interactive users. We put ourselves at risk for failure or inevitable, lack of understanding. But eventually, with time and practice, I think those risks go away.

  3. Devon

    I think the experience itself was what made this movie interesting. Like E-Lit, I don’t exactly know what I was supposed to “get out of it,” but I found it enticing and unique, so I liked it! There isn’t a whole new dynamic experience, like we find in some of the poems we’ve looked at, but the intersection between video, GoogleEarth, and music made this movie fascinating for me. I think the subtle customization (by putting in your home address) is really all this site needs to make it personal. If the goal is to bring back feelings of childhood, it worked for me. Like I’ve said about E-Lit, I feel like some of these new interactive web creations are not entirely about one distinct and obvious meaning, rather, they are about evoking emotion, which I think this movie does quite well.

  4. When you mention control, I immediately thought of the ability to move the windows that pop up over the course of the movie. Am I supposed to move them at all? Should I close them? Which one should I be looking at? I beg to differ about the address being the only differentiation between people’s respective experiences. It would’ve been interesting to “watch” this simultaneously as a class to see what everyone wrote when the “write something to your past self” prompt appeared. Would’ve told a bunch of unique stories in one simple sentence

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

Create a free website or blog at WordPress.com.

%d bloggers like this: